THE CONAN CHRONOLOGY
  • Home
  • R.E.H. CHRONOLOGY
  • Expanded Chronology
  • COMICS
  • NON-CHRON
  • Contact
  • Home
  • R.E.H. CHRONOLOGY
  • Expanded Chronology
  • COMICS
  • NON-CHRON
  • Contact

Ten Years of Question Marks: Investigating the Temporal Space Between "Beyond the Black River" and "Wolves Beyond the Border"

11/2/2026

4 Comments

 
October 22nd's episode of the Legends of Conan podcast was all about "Beyond the Black River," an unassailable Howard classic that is perhaps REH's most interesting story to discuss.

I was passively listening to the episode in my classroom at the end of the school day while grading assignments, but something Howard scholar Jeff Shanks said caused me to put my pen down. 
Jeff alludes to it at the very beginning of the episode, but goes much more into detail after the 52-minute mark. In a unique reading of the chronology of some of the later Conan stories, Jeff places "Beyond the Black River" before Conan's final pirate period. That's an interesting take, but I see the case for it!

"Beyond the Black River" is clearly a story of an older Conan. Everything in that story reads as a very experienced adventurer.

"The Black Stranger" and its de Camp edit "The Treasure of Tranicos" are sometimes placed directly after "Beyond the Black River." I believe this is for two reasons: it opens with Conan having crossed the Pictish Wilderness, and de Camp purposefully edited it to immediately precede Conan's kingship. In terms of chronological elements, it's one of de Camp's most-fucked-with stories.

Usually, these stories are placed as a pair after Conan's final pirate period, and right before his kingship. Essentially, people usually place "Red Nails" as Conan's final pirate story, then we get three Aquilonian stories: "Beyond the Black River," "The Black Stranger," and "Wolves Beyond the Border," before a timeskip sends Conan into his kingship with "The Phoenix on the Sword."
Picture
But Jeff hits on some interesting things in this podcast episode that I don't think many people are aware of. In "Wolves Beyond the Border," the main character, Gault, is a young man. He recounts the fall of Fort Tuscelan in "Beyond the Black River" as having happened when he was ten, and it seems like that was probably around ten years ago, so there's a ten-year time jump between those two stories and Conan's campaign against King Numedides. 

When I did my "Chronologically Speaking" timeline, I don't have any stories between "Black River" and "Wolves" because it made sense to me that Conan would evolve from his Aquilonian scouting role to a more prominent position in the military, and then eventually to a generalship.

The other idea to contend with is the idea that Conan's second pirate period has this length of three years where Conan is shipwrecked and hasn't really been heard from in civilization. I placed "Red Nails" and "Jewels of Gwahlur" during this time, but Jeff had an interesting order to these stories.

He proposes the idea that "Beyond the Black River" comes before Conan's final pirate period, and the ten years between "Black River" and "Wolves" contains that period. I texted him to make sure I had it right, and here's what he said he was thinking:
Picture
I absolutely think Jeff is right about "The Black Stranger" being a pirate story- I have this memory of Howard Days 2026 in which a bunch of us were standing out back of the Howard House, and most of the day was done. Lots of people were cracking beers. Jeff mentioned that Conan ends "The Black Stranger" by going back to being a pirate, and suddenly everything around that time made sense to me. 

I'm not sure I am 100% on Jeff's configuration of breaking up "Black River" from his Aquilonian days, but it's a really interesting argument and makes sense.

UPDATE! CORRECTION!

So Jeff Shanks, the man himself, as shown himself in my comments section here to clarify a few things. You can read his comment below and his discussion with frequent commenter and fellow chronologizer Kenyon Tysklind, but I wanted to clarify a few points in case people don't choose to read the comments. 

​Jeff is making the case for this order of some late-life Conan stories:
Picture
This is a very interesting order to me. Let's explore what Jeff says (lightly edited for some clarity purposes):
Here's a few things we know for certain from the stories. He had two two periods as a pirate as we get two different endings. The first one ended in a shipwreck on a reef 3 years before the events of "The Black Stranger."
We see this when Black Zarono says to Conan: ​"'I thought you were dead,' said Zarono slowly. 'Three years ago the shattered hull of your ship was sighted off a reefy coast, and you were heard of on the Main no more.'"
Beyond the Black River takes place after at least one of the Pirate gigs because he mentions it.
In "Beyond the Black River," Conan says that he had already sailed with the Barachan pirates like this: "​And the coast is dangerous to ships. I've sailed along it when I was with the pirates of the Barachan Isles, which lie southwest of Zingara." This is, I'm assuming, why Jeff places "The Pool of the Black One" prior to "Beyond the Black River."
In "The Black Stranger," he describes the situation on the Aquilonian frontier before he made it across the Pictish Wilderness. The border is the Thunder River and the main frontier province is Conawaga. That is the situation in the aftermath of "Beyond the Black River." And his activities are basically a frontier scout just like in BtBR. So if "The Black Stranger" isn't an immediate sequel to BtBR then you have to posit two different episodes when he was a frontier scout and there's no evidence for that. He also wrote "The Black Stranger" immediately after the sale of BtBR after describing it to Lovecraft.
Here's the line from "The Black Stranger" that Jeff is referring to: "They were the men of the Eagle, whose villages lay far to the east, adjoining the country of the Wolf-Picts. It was the Wolves who had captured him, in a foray against the Aquilonian settlements along Thunder River, and they had given him to the Eagles in return for a captured Wolf chief." This is definitely something that I read differently when I was most recently creating a chronology of these stories. Yes, the settlements are on the Thunder River, something that is in "Beyond the Black River" as well, but I didn't take into account that the Thunder River would be the border between Aquilonian country and Pict country. This makes a lot of sense, because otherwise, the Picts would have had to penetrate through the Black River settlements which are further west than the Thunder River. I definitely stand corrected here. 

I've tried to ignore what Howard was saying and what order things were written in, using only the evidence in the stories, so the last part about Howard writing "Black Stranger" close to "Beyond the Black River" is something I've tried to ignore.

Then "The Black Stranger" ends with Conan sailing away on the Red Hand to begin his second pirate career. As we learn in "Red Nails," this one came to an end when the Zingarans sank his ship off the coast of Shem. And that leads right into "Red Nails."
This is throwing my whole chronology and life into shambles here. The shipwreck mentioned by Black Zarono in "The Black Stranger" does seem to be the same one mentioned in "Red Nails:" ""The Zingarans sank my last ship off the Shemite shore—that's why I joined Zarallo's Free Companions."
Of course, at the end of "Red Nails," he suggests that he might want to start a third pirating career. I think most people have ignored that and just suggested that "Jewels" is the next most logical story, before he heads back north to Aquilonia, But that is definitely more open to interpretation."
I'm currently re-thinking a lot of stuff here! Jeff's obviously an extremely learned scholar about all this stuff- far moreso than me. I'm going to go back to the drawing board for a few of my late-life placements.
4 Comments
Kenyon Tysklind
11/2/2026 12:08:06 pm

Holy shit! I had listened to this the other day, and what Jeff said had stood out to me as well. Before work today I was actually looking over my timeline notes, and was moving stuff around and figured I'd get into later tonight after work. Now, on my break, I open up your website and you have this already laid out. Ha ha! I still really like "The Black Stranger" being before "Beyond the Black River" concept that you proposed in your articles, but I definitely am leaning more towards "Red Nails" and "Bit-Yakin" taking place in between them.

I've been trying to pinpoint where both "Cursed Shores Beyond" and "Tides of the Tyrant King" take place and it looks like it may be in this timeframe. Clearly "Cursed Shores Beyond" is after "Red Nails". but "Tides" is a bit more tricky. For now I have it taking place before "Pool of the Black Ones", but that's really just a placeholder until there a bit more clues.

Again, this is one of the reasons why I love this series so much! So many ways to move things around, and it still makes sense.

Reply
Jeff Shanks link
11/3/2026 12:52:07 pm

Okay so let me make my full case for the following order:
Pool of the black one
Beyond the Black River
The black stranger
Red nails
Wolves Beyond the border

Here's a few things we know for certain from the stories. He had two two periods as a pirate As we get two different endings. The first one ended in a shipwreck on a reef 3 years before the events of the black stranger. Beyond the Black River takes place after at least one of the Pirate gigs because he mentions it. In the black stranger he describes the situation on the aquilonian frontier before he made it across the pictish wilderness. The border is the thunder River and the main frontier province is conawaga. That is the situation in the aftermath of beyond the Black River. And his activities are basically a frontier scout just like in BtBR. So if the black stranger isn't an immediate sequel to BtBR then you have to posit two different episodes when he was a frontier scout and there's no evidence for that. He also wrote The Black stranger immediately after the sale of BtBR after describing it to Lovecraft.

Then the black stranger ends with Conan sailing away on the Red Hand to begin his second pirate career. As we learn in red nails, this one came to an end when the Zingarans sank his ship off the coast of Shem. And that leads right into red nails. Of course, at the end of red nails he suggests that he might want to start a third pirating career. I think most people have ignored that and just suggested that Jewela is the next most logical story, before he heads back north to aquilonia, But that is definitely more open to interpretation

Reply
Kenyon Tysklind
11/3/2026 05:10:15 pm

That timeline layout makes a lot of sense, Jeff (everyone applaud, it's Jeff Shanks!!!). Looking specifically at the gap between Beyond the Black River and Wolves Beyond the Border, I suppose it really comes down to whether Gault was 5 or 10 when the events of "Beyond the Black River" take place. In Draft A he's 5, and in Draft B he's 10.

Now, we know Conan himself was 15 when he took part in his first battle, so it's not crazy to think that maybe Gault is closer to his late teens than a full blown adult, although he is treated with the respect of a fully seasoned warrior. But, to be fair, he was raised during a tumultuous time and area where one would be forced to mature quite quickly.

Might seem like an odd thing to do, but using Legend of Zelda logic, Link is considered an adult at the age of 17, so it's not completely unreasonable to maybe assume Gault is 17?

This slightly closes the gap between the two stories from 10 years to 7 years. Not a huge difference, but for my own purposes, where I have foolishly placed years for each story, this would help consolidate things considerably.

Either way, the best course of action here is to go by draft B's dates, because if we try to have a 15 year gap between Beyond the Black River and Wolves Beyond the Border, I'll cry.

Reply
Jeff Shanks link
11/3/2026 05:16:41 pm

Draft B is definitely the more refined of the two, although it's unfinished. So I think it's safe to go with Gault being 10. It's clear that Howard himself moved from 5 to 10. And yes you can make the case for Gault being 17 or maybe even 16. But in any case there is a good size gap between BtBR and wolves.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Hey, I'm Dan. This is my project reading through the career of everyone's favorite sword-and-sorcery character, Conan the Cimmerian, in chronological order.

    Picture
    Picture

    Archives

    November 2026
    October 2026
    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024

    Categories

    All
    CHRONOLOGICALLY SPEAKING
    COMICS
    CONAN'S DESCENDANTS
    CRITICISM
    Howard Days
    JIREL OF JOIRY
    KANE
    MARVEL COMICS
    PASTICHE
    ROBERT E. HOWARD ORIGINAL
    SAVAGE SWORD OF CONAN
    TITAN COMICS

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly